Binder, Karin and Krauss, Stefan and Bruckmaier, Georg and Marienhagen, Joerg (2018) Visualizing the Bayesian 2-test case: The effect of tree diagrams on medical decision making. PLOS ONE, 13 (3): e0195029. ISSN 1932-6203,
Full text not available from this repository. (Request a copy)Abstract
In medicine, diagnoses based on medical test results are probabilistic by nature. Unfortunately, cognitive illusions regarding the statistical meaning of test results are well documented among patients, medical students, and even physicians. There are two effective strategies that can foster insight into what is known as Bayesian reasoning situations: (1) translating the statistical information on the prevalence of a disease and the sensitivity and the false-alarm rate of a specific test for that disease from probabilities into natural frequencies, and (2) illustrating the statistical information with tree diagrams, for instance, or with other pictorial representation. So far, such strategies have only been empirically tested in combination for "1-test cases", where one binary hypothesis ("disease" vs. "no disease") has to be diagnosed based on one binary test result ("positive" vs. "negative"). However, in reality, often more than one medical test is conducted to derive a diagnosis. In two studies, we examined a total of 388 medical students from the University of Regensburg (Germany) with medical "2-test scenarios". Each student had to work on two problems: diagnosing breast cancer with mammography and sonography test results, and diagnosing HIV infection with the ELISA and Western Blot tests. In Study 1 (N = 190 participants), we systematically varied the presentation of statistical information ("only textual information" vs. "only tree diagram" vs. "text and tree diagram in combination"), whereas in Study 2 (N = 198 participants), we varied the kinds of tree diagrams ("complete tree" vs. "highlighted tree" vs. "pruned tree"). All versions were implemented in probability format (including probability trees) and in natural frequency format (including frequency trees). We found that natural frequency trees, especially when the question-related branches were highlighted, improved performance, but that none of the corresponding probabilistic visualizations did.
| Item Type: | Article |
|---|---|
| Uncontrolled Keywords: | NATURAL FREQUENCIES; ECOLOGICAL RATIONALITY; INDIVIDUAL-DIFFERENCES; DIAGNOSTIC INFERENCES; CONJUNCTION FALLACY; REPRESENTATION; PROBABILITY; NUMBERS; TELL; HIV; |
| Subjects: | 500 Science > 510 Mathematics |
| Divisions: | Mathematics Mathematics > Prof. Dr. Stefan Krauss |
| Depositing User: | Dr. Gernot Deinzer |
| Date Deposited: | 11 Mar 2020 12:56 |
| Last Modified: | 11 Mar 2020 12:56 |
| URI: | https://pred.uni-regensburg.de/id/eprint/14873 |
Actions (login required)
 |
View Item |
